Revisiting the Fabulous Fab

Last summer, Fabrice Tourre didn’t turn around fast enough to see the bus coming at him. Goldman Sachs had given him a big push and put him in the front and center of their big bet on a crash in the residential mortgage securities market.

Tourre ended up as the Fabulous Fab after giving himself that nickname in a series of colorful emails. In one he wrote, “The whole building is about to collapse anytime now,” according to the complaint. “Only potential survivor, the fabulous Fab.”

I still use Tourre as part of my records management policy and education.

The Fabulous Fab Rule: Don’t write emails so provocative that they wind up reproduced on the front page of the Wall Street Journal.

What has happened to Tourre and his colleagues at Goldman Sachs?

Goldman settled the matter for $550 million, with $250 million going to investors and $300 million going to the SEC.

Louise Story and Gretchen Morgenson of the New York Times took another look at the Goldman mortgage desk and the prosecutions against it: S.E.C. Case Stands Out Because It Stands Alone.

According to the article, the SEC looked at Jonathan M. Egol who worked closely with the Fabulous Fab. “But Mr. Egol, now a managing director at the bank, was not named in the case, in part because he was more discreet in his e-mails than Mr. Tourre was, so there was less evidence against him, according to a person with knowledge of the S.E.C.’s case.” That just seems to reinforce the Fabulous Fab Rule.

Also, the story points out that Torre’s trading desk was using a shared email account or listserv to share the messages with the larger group.

The story about the Fabulous Fab Rule gets worse. The New York Times obtained additional information from a lost laptop.

[The information was] provided to The New York Times by Nancy Cohen, an artist and filmmaker in New York also known as Nancy Koan, who says she found the materials in a laptop she had been given by a friend in 2006.  The friend told her he had happened upon the laptop discarded in a garbage area in a downtown apartment building. E-mail messages for Mr. Tourre continued streaming into the device, but Ms. Cohen said she had ignored them until she heard Mr. Tourre’s name in news reports about the S.E.C. case.  She then provided the material to The Times.

That just makes the nightmare worse. An employee is sending out provocative emails, they are going to mass distribution list, and an unsecured laptop is getting the messages.

Sources:

The Fabulous Fab Rule

Don’t write emails so provocative that they wind up reproduced on the front page of the Wall Street Journal.

With many fund managers having to register under the Investment Advisers Act, they will now be subject to more extensive record-keeping requirements. That means more emails will be saved for a longer period of time.

Those questionable emails will preserved for litigants and federal regulators to see, long after you hit the delete button in Outlook.

E-mails from Goldman Sachs Group Inc. director Fabrice Tourre are the center of the case saying Goldman misled investors. In one he wrote, “The whole building is about to collapse anytime now,” according to the complaint. “Only potential survivor, the fabulous Fab.”

(I need to give credit to Kevin LaCroix of The D&O Diary for the new name for this rule: The Essential Lessons of the “Faithless Servant”.)

Here is another great email quote from the Fabulous Fab:

“When I think that I had some input into the creation of this product (which by the way is a product ofpure intellectual masturbation, the type of thing which you invent telling yourself: “Well, what if we created a “thing”, which has no purpose, which is absolutely conceptual and highly theoretical and which nobody knows how to price ?”) it sickens the heart to see it shot down in mid-flight. .. It’s a little like Frankenstein turning against his own inventor;)”

The other detrius that ended up in front of the Senate Subcommittee on Investigations were the email love letters from Fab to his girlfriend. Another reminder to keep personal email off the company’s network and company time.

Sources:

Goldman Settles; Fabulous Fab is Left on His Own

Goldman Sachs settled with the Securities and Exchange Commission. That’s not a surprise. Goldman did not want to litigate this action. It wanted it to go away.

As a shareholder in Goldman, I wanted it to go away. It seems others did also. GS stock price opened at $138.50 on Thursday morning. It opened at $151.47 this morning. That’s a 10% increase based on the settlement. The stock has been down 21% since the SEC filed its complaint.

Goldman is going pay $550 million, with $250 million going to investors and $300 million going to the SEC. The dollar amount is not a surprise. I assumed the top dollar amount was the $1 billion lost by investors. I think the time it took between the filing of the action and the settlement was largely focused on how much Goldman was going to pay to make this ugly incident go away.

That is a big dollar amount. As SEC enforcement director Robert Khuzami points out, it’s the biggest SEC fine against a Wall Street firm. There have been bigger fines in other industries.

According to Footnoted, Goldman has $27 billion is cash and short term securities. It’s big dollar number, but Goldman can find that much the cash by looking under the cushions on its couch.

Unfortunately for Goldman VP Fabrice Tourre, he is not included in the settlement. The SEC is continuing its litigation against him. Fabulous Fab has a Monday deadline to respond to the SEC complaint. Fab still works at Goldman but is on paid leave.

He is trying to clear his name. Goldman just paid to get theirs back.

Sources: