China is hotbed for violations of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act. The real estate industry is not immune from the dangers. In February of 2009 Morgan Stanley’s real estate group reported an employee based in China in an overseas real estate subsidiary that appeared to have violated the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act.
My company has significant business relationships with CB Richard Ellis so it saddens me that they are the latest to report a problem under the FCPA.
As a result of an internal investigation that began in the first quarter of 2010, the Company determined that some of its employees in certain of its offices in China made payments in violation of Company policy to local governmental officials, including payments for non-business entertainment and in the form of gifts. The payments the Company discovered are minor in amount and the Company believes relate to only a few discrete transactions involving immaterial revenues. Nonetheless, the Company believes that the payments may have been in violation of the U.S. Foreign Corrupt Practices Act or other applicable laws. Consequently, the Company voluntarily disclosed these events to the U.S. Department of Justice (the “DOJ”) and the Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) on February 27, 2010 and has continued to cooperate with both the DOJ and the SEC in connection with this investigation. The Company engaged outside counsel to investigate these events and has implemented thorough remedial measures.
In addition, in the third quarter of 2010, the Company began another internal investigation, with the assistance of outside counsel, involving the use of a third party agent in connection with a purchase in 2008 of an investment property in China for one of the funds the Company manages through its Global Investment Management business. This investigation is ongoing and at this point the Company is unable to predict the duration, scope or results thereof. In light of the Company’s cooperation with the DOJ and the SEC as described above, the Company voluntarily notified both agencies of this separate internal investigation and will report back to them when the Company has more information.
The real estate industry should be just as concerned about bribery of foreign officials as any other industry. Perhaps even more so. Real estate is inherently local and you undoubtedly need to deal with government officials to get building permits, occupancy permits, zoning approvals and a myriad of other interactions.
- CB Richard Ellis Group Inc. 8-K filed 5 October 2010
- CB Richard Ellis: China Employees Paid Government Officials by Joe Palazzolo in WSJ.com’s Corruption Currents
- CB Richard Says Some Employees Made China Payments by Danielle Kucera in Bloomberg Business Week
- Morgan Stanley Self-Reports FCPA Violation – prior post on Compliance Building